Warning: This one is not gluten free unless you use gluten free bread and contains diary and eggs. You can easily make your substitutions and I find the flavor is still amazing!. At this time of year, I am always running to an event at church, work or charity. I was raised with the firm belief system that it is rude to arrive anywhere empty handed!! So this recipe is wonderful if you have no time and want to bake something yummy that will please seems to please a large crowd. Making it the night before seems to give it a more pudding like consistency but I find even a hour soak is fine if you are in a rush. Just remember to preheat the oven. A couple of tips:
1.) Cut the crust off to make a more pudding like consistency. You can really use sweet potato puree as I did in this recipe, but pumpkin or even pumpkin pie filling will work. The pie filling is not as viscous (thick) and it will produce a more pudding like consistency.
2.) The bread: Good choice are a thick white, Sourdough, Brioche, I have even made this with Rye or Brown breads and it gave it a wonderful salty taste! I found that if you use actual pumpkin bread, it becomes overly sweet.
3.) Topping you can omit the nuts or add some steel cut oats, make a streusel topping, drizzle with maple bourbon syrup, brown sugar, bacon, walnuts.
4.) The longer it soaks the better it is. I have also added little pockets of goat cheese, cream cheese or even brie a few times sprinkled in to give it a new twist.
5.) This recipe is double for a deep casserole dish measuring 4″ deep. You may not use all of the bread or you can put this into two shallow casseroles depending on the thickness of your bread.
6.) Salt and pepper are optional, but I do find it brings out a little more flavor. Also you may of course use fresh purees and fresh ground spices, but watch your quantities as they will be more pungent in taste especially the ginger.
PUMPKIN BREAD PUDDING OR SWEET POTATO BREAD PUDDING
(DOUBLE BATCH)
Casserole dish (approx. 9 x 13- deep dish) or two smaller ones
Non-stick cooking spray or oil of choice
20 slices of bread (Stale if possible, but not required), gluten free works well too
2 cans (15 ounces each) of pumpkin or sweet potato puree or fresh puree
1 and 1/3 cup of sugar (note: you can use any kind here, but the larger granulated may not dissolve completely, you can also add a little more or less to taste)
2 tsp Ground Cinnamon (note if grating fresh sticks, this may be more pungent so add a little at first, then more to taste)
1 tsp Ground Ginger (Again if grating fresh, use sparingly to taste)
1 tsp ground nutmeg (same thing if grating fresh)
NOTE: IF YOU ARE IN A RUSH PUMPKIN PIE SPICE HAS ALL OF THIS IN THERE AND YOU CAN ADD TWO TBSP OR MORE TO TASTE.
1/4 tsp salt (try not to use iodized) – optional
1/4 tsp fresh ground pepper (black if possible) – optional
12 eggs – For this recipe I used large Grade A but if using fresh or organic you may need an egg or two extra. Beat well before adding
2 cups of milk – I use whole fat but any milk will do even goats milk, almond or soy
2 cans (14 ounces each) of evap milk – if using substitutions, you can just add more milk
Toppings: On this recipe I used chopped pecans and brown sugar, but see above notes you can use anything.
Instructions:
Spray you cooking sheet with non-stick baking spray or oil of choice (Canola works well and won’t impart any flavors. Cut bread into cubes of size of your choice and place in the pan (don’t mound them , you want this nice and level). If adding nuts and you want them evenly sprinkled in, add them in as you ad in the bread crumbs so they will be evenly distributed in the dish. Mix all ingredients well and soak at least and hour if possible but overnight will yield the best results. Cover with plastic wrap if using overnight and as it has eggs while it is soaking always refrigerate.
If you want it steamier, then put it covered with alum foil in a pre-heated 350 degree (Fahrenheit) oven. Bake for approx. 45 minutes to one hour. If baking with a very cold dish, it may take longer in the oven. Take off the Alum foil for the last 15-20 minute to give it a toasty brown topping. If checking for temp, it should reach an internal temp of 160 degree (Fahrenheit) and check in a few places if a deep dish.
Serve with Crème Anglaise, Bourbon Maple Glaze, Crumbled Bacon, whatever make you happy!! I will post my Creme Anglaise recipe shortly as well as Maple Bourbon Glaze or serving sauce. Enjoy! Pictures shortly but I have to race this over to church!!